You have chosen a quotation, but your paragraph stops immediately after it. How can you show a reader why that detail matters? The paragraph framework associated with Jane Schaffer gives you a way to separate evidence from your explanation. Start with a claim, introduce a specific detail, and use commentary to connect the two.
Schaffer paragraph: The basic parts
A Jane Schaffer paragraph commonly includes a topic sentence, concrete detail, commentary, and a concluding sentence. In a frequently taught version for literary analysis, one sentence of concrete detail is followed by two sentences of commentary. A detail and its accompanying explanation form a “chunk”; a paragraph can include more than one chunk.
A 2009 Yale-New Haven Teachers Institute unit describes the detail-to-commentary distinction and the one-to-two pattern. A 2009 school writing guide likewise connects evidence and explanation. Follow your assignment if its directions differ.
Here’s what each part does:
- Topic sentence (TS): States the paragraph’s main claim.
- Concrete detail (CD): Offers specific evidence, such as a relevant action, fact, or quotation.
- Commentary (CM): Interprets the detail and explains how it supports the claim.
- Concluding sentence (CS): Brings the point to a close or connects it to the larger argument.
The pattern is a scaffold, not a universal rule that makes every paragraph good. Your ideas and the assignment determine how much evidence and explanation you need. Counting sentences cannot replace reasoning; it can, however, remind you to make room for it.
Read an original passage
The following short passage is fictional and was written for this exercise:
The rain stopped before the school fair opened. While the other volunteers folded their umbrellas, Nora checked the paper signs at every table. At the last table, she smoothed one damp corner and placed a stone on it.
Suppose the question asks what Nora’s actions suggest about her attitude toward the fair. A useful claim might say she cares about making the event ready for visitors. The signs and the stone are evidence; her concern for visitors is an interpretation drawn from that evidence, not a sentence the passage states directly.
See the parts working together
This Jane Schaffer paragraph responds to the passage:
[TS] Nora’s careful actions suggest that she wants the fair to be ready for its visitors. [CD] After the rain, she checks the signs and holds down a damp corner with a stone. [CM] Her attention to a small problem suggests she is thinking about whether people will be able to read the sign. [CM] Fixing it before the fair opens also shows preparation rather than waiting for someone else to notice. [CS] Nora’s quiet work helps present her as a thoughtful volunteer.
The claim is arguable, and the detail describes Nora’s action. The first comment connects the sign to its purpose; the second examines timing. The conclusion returns to the larger impression.
The labels are for practice. In a finished paragraph, remove them unless your teacher asks you to keep them. If you quote a published text, identify and cite it as your assignment requires. A paraphrase also needs attribution; changing the words does not make the evidence yours.
Give the detail something to do
Here is a weak response using the same passage:
Nora is thoughtful. She checks the signs and puts a stone on one. This shows that she is thoughtful.
The evidence fits the claim, but the last sentence repeats the conclusion rather than explaining it. Ask: What problem might the stone solve? Why does it matter that Nora acts before visitors arrive? Then revise:
Nora’s attention to the signs suggests that she is preparing for visitors. She checks each sign and puts a stone on a damp corner. The stone may keep the paper in place so visitors can read it. By fixing the problem before the fair opens, she anticipates a need instead of waiting for a complaint.
This revision has a visible connection between action and interpretation. “May” is useful because the passage does not say exactly what Nora is thinking. A Schaffer-style paragraph should be grounded in what the text supports, not a confident guess about an unseen motive.
Use the structure without getting stuck
Jane Schaffer writing instruction names steps in building an argument. Mark the claim, evidence, and explanation. Add reasoning where needed; if a detail cannot support the commentary, narrow the claim or choose better evidence.
A paragraph based on Schaffer’s method may use two chunks when one example is not enough. Each new detail needs commentary of its own. Do not add another quotation just to fill a slot: ask what it contributes. If a teacher specifies a ratio or particular structure, meet that requirement. Otherwise, let the purpose and evidence guide the length.
In an essay or news analysis, distinguish verified information from interpretation and explain the link.
Practice writing commentary
Read this new fictional passage:
Before the team presentation, Luis notices that the projector is unplugged. He connects it, tests the first slide, and tells his partner the image is ready.
Claim: Luis helps the team prepare.
Concrete detail: He connects the projector and tests the first slide.
Write two sentences of commentary. Explain what the test accomplishes and how telling his partner contributes to preparation. Then compare your response with this example:
Testing the slide lets Luis check whether the presentation can be displayed before the audience arrives. Telling his partner that the image is ready shares useful information with the team and reduces uncertainty about the equipment.
Both sentences explain why an action matters; neither simply repeats the detail. You could reasonably write a different explanation, provided it follows from the passage. Check that your commentary supports the claim and does not invent a result, such as a successful presentation that the passage never describes.